Thursday, March 10, 2011

Baby Steps of a Beginning Criminal

          The modern day teenagers may be enthusiastic and friendly, but society often forgets they are also young thieves. A common pastime of theirs is finding websites to download their favourite songs for free. This is incontrovertibly illegal, as the act of taking objects without a form of payment is against the law. Stealing music is a prominent issue that everyone labels as immoral. Generations before us have lived without illegal downloading; therefore, modern society should be no different. The only excuse today's teenagers have is that they are too cheap to pay cash. Yet, they're simultaneously setting themselves up for prison; furthermore, they are manipulating the leniency of the British Columbia Youth Justice Act. Perhaps the only solution is to teach them that downloading music is no different from stealing equipment in a recording studio. Once this message is conveyed, adolescents will understand they have the power to refuse illegal activity or face a life as a criminal.

3 comments:

  1. Stealing music is a prominent issue that everyone labels as immoral = Hasty generalization

    Generations before us have lived without illegal downloading; therefore, modern society should be no different = appeal to tradition

    Perhaps the only solution is to teach them that downloading music is no different from stealing equipment in a recording studio. = weak analogy

    Good job on this one kaitlin, your writing skills make it harder to find the fallacies

    ReplyDelete
  2. thank you mio! And with regard to your last sentence, that could also be due to poor integration or misinterpretations on my behalf. But I appreciate your unfailing support. : )

    ReplyDelete
  3. "The only excuse today's teenagers have is that they are too cheap to pay cash" - Ad hominem

    "They are manipulating the leniency of the British Columbia Youth Justice Act" - Straw man

    "Once this message is conveyed, adolescents will understand they have the power to refuse illegal activity or face a life as a criminal" - False dichotomy

    ReplyDelete